Above – Jennifer Flowers, Peter O'Brien, Eden Falk, Anthony Phelan, Tom Stokes, Mia Morrissey and Nicholas Hammond. Photo – Jeff-Busby.

A loud burst of foreboding music as the lights go down on Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None is an effective jump scare for the audience – and an apt scene setter.

Whether you’re a lover of theatrical thrillers or have never seen one before, this production of the best-selling mystery novel of all time has something to pique your interest.

And Then There Were None tells the story of ten strangers who are invited to a solitary mansion on an island off the English coast. Cut off from the mainland, the true reason for their presence on the island becomes, all too quickly, horribly clear.

Something that immediately situates the audience in this story is the set. It is both beautiful and realistic, cleverly designed and skillfully executed. It serves the narrative well in its adaptability to reflect the different moods throughout the play, assisted by effective lighting, most notably contributing to the sense of oppression as the play goes on.

Another element that really draws the audience in is the staging of the deaths. Some are dramatic and bold, and some more subtle and chilling – it’s a good mix that comes together through clever stagecraft and expert execution. It is thrilling to have deaths staged right in front of you that you don’t notice until it’s too late.

This is part of the expertise in Agatha Christie's writing, that you as an audience member are on the same journey to hurriedly try and identify the killer that the characters are. Likewise, the same way that the characters’ assumptions and prejudices become apparent through who they suspect, we too become aware of our assumptions as we try to unmask the killer. Who do I trust? Who do I suspect? Why?

The play is a fantastic ensemble piece and was done justice with a strong ensemble cast. The standout performance was Mia Morrissey as Vera Claythorne, whose presence, grace and honesty in her performance made her captivating to watch. Honourable mentions to Tom Stokes as Philip Lombard and Grant Piro as Rogers.

And Then There Were None is an interesting exploration of sin, guilt, morality and the cost of taking a human life. These dark themes are well balanced with high entertainment value in a production that leaves its audience horrified, pensive and entertained all at once.

Event details

John Frost for Crossroads Live presents
And Then There Were None
by Agatha Christie

Director Robyn Nevin

Venue: Comedy Theatre, Melbourne VIC
Dates: until 23 March 2025
Bookings: www.andthentherewerenone.com.au

ALSO TOURING
Sydney from May 2025
Perth from June 2025
Adelaide from August 2025

Most read Melbourne reviews

  • GRIMM | Shake & Stir Theatre Co
    GRIMM | Shake & Stir Theatre Co
    Spells, rules and the fourth wall are consistently broken in this chaotic retelling of some of the Grimm Brother’s most famous fairy tales.
  • The Memory Mirror | G Luck Productions
    The Memory Mirror | G Luck Productions
    This work regularly feels like a short story that has not been adequately shaped into a play
  • Hotsy-Totsy | 2026 Melbourne Fringe Festival
    Hotsy-Totsy | 2026 Melbourne Fringe Festival
    The show is aiming for silliness, and its successful realisation here is certainly a nice change of pace from the worries of the modern world.
  • La Bohème | Opera Australia
    La Bohème | Opera Australia
    Faithful to the spirit of the libretto yet refreshingly original in its visual interpretation, Costi’s production moves effortlessly between theatrical extravagance and emotional intimacy.
  • An Evening Without Kate Bush
    An Evening Without Kate Bush
    Young efficiently managed various costume changes to transport us to different eras of the Bush legacy. The vocals are consistently of a high-quality, even through the demands of some very physical dancing to a backing track.