The Cherry Orchard | Winterfall TheatreLeft - David Lamb and Marissa Ben. Photo - Alex De La Rambelie

Is it a comedy? There are some fine moments of humour and much irony in The Cherry Orchard but pathos and poignancy as well, especially in this production by Winterfall Theatre (using a modern translation by playwright Sir Tom Stoppard). Chekhov’s famed play is presented with verve, the cast creating an unholy sense of claustrophobia, tension and decay along with a subtly contemporary mood. There’s an elegant sense of timelessness about this production, crammed as it is into the intimacy of Husk Theatre’s minimalist space. When a production makes you feel like you’re part of the proceedings and you have to hold yourself back from joining in, then something’s going right.

The team is led by Winterfall's co-director, Michele Williams, as Liubov, extraordinary as the needy self-destructive mother on the verge of a nervous breakdown. They’re all good; Trent Baker’s direction has a sure touch and the tone of the play sits well between the laughs and the tragedy. Justin Hosking brings an Aussie male sensibility to his Lopachin; the character is familiar yet still right at home in the period setting. There is a palpable sexual tension between him and Liubov, beautifully calibrated by the expressive Williams. Kasia Kazmareck elegantly understates the unfulfilled Varya waiting in vain on Lopachin’s proposal. The stoic Phil Roberts (sustaining a painful injury) is unnervingly poignant as Gayev, confluent with his sister’s denial and delusion. The ancient Firs is ably presented by Kirk Alexander; his demise at the end completely believable. The Cherry Orchard is a populous play but here the cast are well individuated and the story easy to follow so there’s no danger of getting lost.

The actors’ dishevelled costumes illustrate the gradual destruction of their physical world along with the declining of their respective psychologies and that of the social privilege they once enjoyed. The old order is changing and the fortunes of this once prosperous landowning family parallel the changes in Russian society leading up to 1912. Being so close to the actors creates an odd intimacy with the performers, their moments of human vulnerability particularly, but not unbearably, intense. Yet there is a self-containment about the production, too, despite the emotionality we witness, to do with the fact that each individual is ultimately weak and self-concerned, unable to effectively support one another; the family structure is as fragile as the soon-to-be demolished cherry orchard.

Baker avoids having the family watching through the window as the trees are felled, the enormity of the loss is reflected rather in Liubov’s lonely sorrowing. There is a strong sense of the inevitability of the family destruction, both in their relationships and finances, so much so that the fact of the orchard coming down doesn’t feel as sad as the family’s coming apart; the loss of the trees is appreciated here more on a symbolic level.

Winterfall Theatre gives us a fine version of this well-loved play, accessible and convincing. A delight well worth seeking out.

Winterfall Theatre Company Presents
by Anton Chekhov | translated by Tom Stoppard

Directed by Trent Baker

Venue: The Theatre Husk | 161a Heidelberg Road Northcote
Dates: 24 Feb – 20 March, 2011
Times: Thurs - Sat @7.30pm; Sun @6pm
Tickets: $26/$32
Bookings: |

Most read Melbourne reviews

Master of the deadpan, harsh host of Hard Quiz, and heartless interrogator on Hard Chat, making...

It doesn’t matter how much you know or care about the legality of the Essendon Football Club...

If you’re looking for a show that’s completely different and unlike anything you’ve seen in...

For fans of the musical, the problems and changes to the book and plot of Chess are as familiar...

Swapping 16th Century Verona for 1930s Hollywood, and a lengthy title for the short and snappy...