Tuesday, 25 April 2017
Sydney » Reviews »
The Duel | Sydney Theatre Company and ThinIce
Written by Augusta Supple   
Wednesday, 10 June 2009 11:52
The Duel | Sydney Theatre Company and ThinIceLeft - Luke Mullins. Cover - Luke Mullins and Brian Lipson. Photos - Tracey Schramm

Trapped in a narrow beige room the length of the stage, without a door but with a window, are four actors waiting. Shoes and socks off lounging, standing, crouching- watching the audience. The Duel has begun. Actor and audience in a duel with each other: watching each other: waiting.

Next Stage is the development arm of the Sydney Theatre Company designed to assist artists in the development of new work. Since the start of the year, this has included Bell Shakespeare's "Mind's Eye" project Venus and Adonis directed by Marion Potts and Griffin Theatre's production of Ross Mueller's Concussion directed by Brett Adam. The Duel is the third production nurtured by Perth based company Thin Ice, headed by Matthew Lutton. This is a truly magnificent opportunity for artists to explore ideas, and create work in an alternative venue with a high level of production support for which the Sydney Theatre Company should be applauded.
Taken from a chapter of Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov, Tom Wright’s adaptation, directed by Matthew Lutton is an experimentation of form and genre, exploring the question which faces text-based storytellers: at what point does literature become a performance? Where as many theatrical pieces aim to show a “slice of life”, The Duel shows a slice of literature. Literature as accessible in trackpants, dunlop volleys and hooded sweatshirts: literature for the here and now. Dostoevsky’s story is not shown, but told through monologue, an occasional demonstration of events and an erratic sound track. This performance is the telling, not a showing of transformative choices within every person and dares the audience to engage with a conversation about guilt and freedom, responsibility, punishment and forgiveness.

A small ensemble of performers Luke Mullins, Brian Lipson, David Lee Smith and Renee McIntosh play multiple roles and ambiguously float between character, performer and audience to the story. With a simple claustrophobic set design and contemporary costume design by Claude Marcos, beautiful and transformative lighting design by Damien Cooper and creative sound design by Kingsley Reeve - the world of this story telling is at times beautiful, poetic and dull with domesticity: without an obvious meta-theatrical framing. This is a presentation of literature with theatrical design elements. The effect is one of academia: we can see what is happening, we are asked questions directly by the characters, we are told of the effects of a confession and its effects. We are asked to imagine these characters enacted by the actors which could be understood as an exploration of Brecht’s Verfremdungseffekt. In The Duel, we see the exploration of movement, of the non-verbal, of gestural, a collision of the contemporary stage craft and an antique Russian rumination.

According to the program notes, Lutton had “no desire to substantially dramatise the events of the chapter”, and moments are indeed enacted: but with the character of Zosima narrating the event complete with his internal reasoning. We follow Zosima’s transformation from sibling, to soldier, to monk: assisted by personal illuminations, he explores the moment of change: significant personal change when a decision is made to put down a gun and fight, when a decision is made that the time to confess has come, when the decision to leave is the only decision left. Challenging questions collide with beautiful ideas of love, passion, rational thinking, connectedness and individualism and the duel is really a battle between grey moral principles.

Though a thoroughly engaging story, I am left asking questions of my own. Would I have understood, engaged with or been transformed by this story as much if I were to have read this story? Book in my lap, tea in hand? What is the value of a reading? Would I have understood this story as much if this was a radio play? After all it was the reading of this story (chapter) by Lutton which inspired him: if he had seen a production would it have had such a resonating effect?

Sydney Theatre Company and ThinIce present
adapted by Tom Wright
from The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Venue: Wharf 2, Sydney Theatre Company, Hickson Road, Walsh Bay
Dates: 5 – 20 June 2009
Times: Tuesdays - Saturdays 8.15pm, Mondays 7pm
Matinees: Saturdays 2.15pm
Tickets: $25 - $45
Bookings: 9250 1777 www.sydneytheatre.com.au/next-stage
Pin It

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

PozibleAustralian Stage JobsMembers Area

Most Read SYDNEY Reviews

The Popular Mechanicals | Sydney Theatre Company
Taking Bottom the weaver and his fellow gormless tradies with dreams of amateur theatrical stardom, playwrights Keith Robin...
Talk | Sydney Theatre Company
There are several clear issues with Sydney Theatre Company's latest production. Tweet !function(d,s,id)}(doc...
Faster | The Australian Ballet
Faster is modern ballet in its truest form. The production is segmented into three works, completely unlike each other. The...
Horrible Harriet | CDP Theatre Producers
Sydney Opera House and CDP Theatre Producers present the opportunity to see Horrible Harriet in all her glory live on stage...
Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo | Mad March Hare and Red Line Productions
The marvellous Maggie Dence behind a fence in fine feline form plays the titular tiger in Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo....