Friday, 22 September 2017
Sydney » Reviews »
Brahms' 'Fifth Symphony' | Sydney Symphony
Written by lloyd bradford (brad) syke   
Sunday, 13 April 2008 21:20
Not every symphony tells a story, as such; but every symphonic poem does. As against the former’s abstraction, the latter, typically, takes its cues from folkloric tales. In the 19th century, the symphonic poem was as popular as hip-hop is today, and ‘humble Czech musician’ (as he thought of himself), Antonin Dvorak, wrote no less than five, four of which are based on a collection of ballads by Karel Jaromir Erben, whose birth predated Dvorak’s by 30 years. One, The Noon Witch, which (no pun intended), by the standards of the time, at around 14 minutes duration, was a veritable 2.5-minute pop song, opened the Emirates Metro Series Brahms ‘Fifth Symphony’ concert, in the Concert Hall, at the Sydney Opera House, last night. And what an evocative piece it is! To borrow another cliché, a picture might be worth a thousand words, but so it can be with music, when it raises the curtain on the theatre of the mind, by richly and powerfully evoking imagery and, moreover, redolent atmosphere, in the way this piece does. Insofar as its success in this, it recalls, say, the power of something like Peter & The Wolf; that has text, too, of course, while this doesn’t need it. Moreover, the SSO, in fine fettle, under the baton of guest conductor, Paul Daniel, brought it and its characters to vivid life.

(If the kids are playing up and you’re not averse to the Victorian adage of ‘children should be seen and not heard', you can always relate the tale of the midday crone stealing away overly vocal kiddies. Or take them along to the next performance.)

The centrepiece of the suite of performances was Ernest Bloch’s Schelomo, one of his most notable works. Luckily for the rest of us, Bloch escaped the family clock business, vowing, as the story goes, from the tender age of 10, to become a composer. He can be considered a Jewish composer, in more ways than one: not just by dint of his birthright, but by his musical preoccupations; his themes, while not always directly referencing Hebraic sources, are nonetheless infused with those flavours. There are a couple of apocryphal stories that pertain to how he came to write the piece, which would easily flesh out an episode of Classic Albums, or something, but the real news, on the night, was the appearance by Texan violoncello virtuoso, Ralph Kirshbaum, who graced the stage for the full 20-odd minute length. Kirshbaum is, clearly, a passionate player and it’s this, to the untrained eye and ear, at least, that makes all the difference. Sure, it makes for an entertaining visual spectacle, watching his almost hyperventilated gestures, but it’s more than palpable in the performance; on a very distinguished ’cello, to boot. One can, literally, hear the conviction: not only Kirshbaum’s belief in the music, but Bloch’s; it’s almost as if RK is channelling the intentions of the rather serious young composer. It was a masterful and delightfully idiosyncratic rendition, which gathered optimal energy from the considerable collective force of the SSO. In case your Hebrew’s a little lacking, Schelomo, of course, translates as Solomon, as in the virile king; (biblically, he had as many as 700 wives and 300 concubines).

By the way, if you go out of yours to give this ‘Blochbuster’ a listen (which you can, 7pm, this coming Tuesday evening, April 14, via 92.9 ABC Classic FM, don’t expect the classic(al) big finish: to quote Katherine Kemp, ‘it dies, at the end, lonely in its grief’.

Last, but, by no means, least, we heard the eponymous Brahms’ (so-called) ‘5th’; so called, because, ’though, at root, the Brahms’ Piano Quartet in G Minor (Opus 25), this is Arnold Scoenberg’s orchestral take. Today, we call it plagiarism; then, it was homage. I jest. Schoenberg took the time and trouble purely and simply because he liked the piece and felt it criminally underexposed; when played, he found it played badly. This was his fix.

’Twas a good move to borrow Paul Daniel from his soon-to-be principal conductorship of the WASO. Many’s the smile I caught from other audience-members, clearly delighted by Schoenberg’s and the orchestra’s dramatics, but, above all, by Daniel’s almost Chaplinesque ‘batonic’ eccentricities. Schoenberg isn’t everyone’s cup o’ soup. Even he knew: ‘if people speak of me, they connect me with horror’. Brahms, by contrast, has put many of us to sleep; in a good way. The coming together might seem unlikely, a little like a collaboration between Henry Rollins & Britney (well, you know), but closer examination shows it to be almost inevitable: Schoenberg’s first composition teacher was a JB charge and his classes amply reflected this bias; AS performed Brahms’ chamber music, as a string-player; Schoenberg even wrote an essay in which he declaimed his profound love for the older composer (in the best musical sense). He has brought this, in spades, to his orchestration of JB’s piano quartet and, once again, the SSO has, through its musicality, professionalism and rigour, but, more than anything, vigour, made this very real and, in the final movement, electrifying.


Sydney Symphony Orchestra
Brahms’ ‘Fifth Symphony’

Venue: Sydney Opera House
Dates/Times: Thu 10 Apr 1.30pm; Fri 11 Apr 8pm; Sat 12 Apr 2pm; Mon 14 Apr 7pm
Bookings: Sydney Symphony Box Office: 02 8215 4600 or This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
Pin It

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
PozibleAustralian Stage JobsMembers Area
 

Most Read SYDNEY Reviews

Monteverdi Vespers | The Song Company
As soon as I heard that Australia’s premier vocal ensemble was teaming up with its most exciting early music orchestra, I r...
Sunday in the Park with George | Little Triangle
This is a brave choice and a wonderful debut production for this new company. It is melodic, funny, and moving – and well w...
Assassins | Hayes Theatre Co
Given the current state of both American and Australian politics, both fixated on silencing the voices of diversity, it is...
My Fair Lady
Truly – the best example of all the joy, delight and emotion that can come with a genuinely crafted and massive musical the...
Figaro | Genesian Theatre
Adultery, infidelity, debauchery, in flagrante and a hint of incest, Charles Morey’s reworking of Beaumarchais’ Figaro is m...

More Reviews By 'lloyd bradford (brad) syke'