Saturday, 23 September 2017
The Lower Depths
Written by Nic Velissaris   
Sunday, 02 November 2008 21:40
The Lower DepthsLeft - Chloe Armstrong. Image - Jeff Busby

The Lower Depths
by Maxim Gorky is considered to be the Russian’s playwright’s masterpiece; a play that chronicles the lives of the underclass living in a doss house in Moscow in the early years of the twentieth century. Ariette Taylor, who has spent the better part of seven years bringing this production to the stage, has crafted a work that is bold, ambitious and above all humane.

This production is a revelation, in many senses of the word, revealing not only its beauty and elegance but also its underlying motivations and theatricality as it unfolds.

But first a caveat: The Lower Depths is a work of classic theatre. It makes no apologies for its large cast, and long running time (approximately three hours). For those theatregoers who prefer their theatre in small bite-sized hour-long performances with a cast of no more than four, be warned, this is not that kind of show.

At the spiritual core of the show is Alex Menglet’s Luka (or as is he is referred to by the others, ‘Grandpa’ or ‘Old Man’) whose arrival at the doss house signals not only the end of the long-suffering Anna’s life (played beautifully by Genevieve Picot) but the beginning of a new kind of hope, which inspires the inhabitants of the house to raise themselves up from their situation.  

The Lower Depths is a performance in which everyone is given the opportunity to shine. Each actor has their moment to hold the stage and reveal some insight about their character. Ariette Taylor has assembled an amazing ensemble to realise this work: Chloe Armstrong, Heather Bolton, Syd Brisbane, Marco Chiappi, Luke Elliot, Paul English, Bessie Holland, Alex Menglet, Denis Moore, Stewart Morritt, Natalia Novikova, Genevieve Picot, Adam Pierzchalski, Malcolm Robertson and Greg Stone

It’s no doubt that different viewers will have their own favourite characters, and for me these included Greg Stone’s tragicomic Actor, Denis Moore’s diabolical Kostylyov and the simplicity and completeness of Bessie Holland’s Kvashnya. Although it is unfair to single out any one performer, because as ensemble they are peerless: they are all performers who revel in the world they are creating and in turn invite the audience to become a part of their journey.

Many of the cast have worked with Taylor before during her collaboration with Daniel Keene on the Keene/Taylor Theatre Project, and it is no doubt this familiarity that enables Taylor to elicit the performances that she does. The show is also strengthened by Adrienne Chisolm’s clever and economical set design and Emma Valente’s elegant and understated lighting design.

As a narrative Gorky’s play does not offer neat solutions, or even a linear path, instead it offers a collection of moments that when strung together reveal the lives of the people who inhabit his story. Perhaps why The Lower Depths works so well is the unique approach that Taylor has taken to adapting this text. Alex Menglet, a native Russian speaker, translated the script word for word, and then this script was given to the actors to interpret. This could have been a recipe for disaster, but instead we have a translation that not only uniquely fits the mouth of each actor, but also succeeds in explaining the complex emotions involved in this very Russian play and making it accessible and relevant to an Australian audience.

It has to be said that this is the type of production that the Melbourne Theatre Company should be doing and for whatever reason isn’t and it is to the credit of Taylor and the venue fortyfivedownstairs for realising and filling that gap. 

A simple epitaph for The Lower Depths would be: It must be seen.
This is because The Lower Depths is the theatre event of the year.

Ariette Taylor and fortyfivedownstairs present
The Lower Depths
by Maxim Gorky

Venue: fortyfivedownstairs | 45 Flinders Lane Melbourne  
Previews: Wed 29 Oct & Thur 30 Oct at 7.30pm
Dates: 31 October to 29 November
Times: Tuesday to Saturday 8pm (except Wednesday & Sunday 6.30pm, Saturday matinee 29 Nov 2.30pm
Bookings: (03) 9662 9966 or at
Pin It

Comments (2)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
Watching "The Lower Depths" you get the feeling that apart from few scenes this show is really good old traditional dialog and monolog delivery. Yes, most actors have an opportunity to shine delivering their lines, but the whole play seems like a basketball game made of superstars who's the only purpose is to score individually to win the game but not passing the ball to make it an interesting show.

And the show is static. Actors appear and disappear and but most of the time they have nothing to do apart from lot's of gesturing. While the set design is interesting and minimalistic the lack of creative solutions for each scene leaves actors to do what they do best - deliver their lines. And if not for Alex Menglet, Natalia Novikova and Adam Pierzchalski delivering some kind of Russian authenticity to this otherwise very Anglo-Saxon approach to Gorky - some characters are straight from Shakespeare, some are form Underbelly and some are from Home and Away leaving you with the feeling that you have been flipping channels with your TV remote.

With the exception of few scenes where the audience is waken up with grand singing scene or Adam Pierzchalski's drunk-accordion-savvy Alyoshka's interventions, the whole production is amazingly minimalistic with the use of sound as it is with their use of lighting design.

But the biggest minimalist of this production is the director of the play. No matter how deep Ariette Taylor tries to submerge the audience, it leaves you with the feeling that we are safely swimming in the shallow waters here. It's just not deep enough.

Theatre Patron
Theatre Patron , November 10, 2008
This was an amazing piece of theatre. Well done to all involved. I don't think Melbourne was ready for it.
kk , November 29, 2008

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

PozibleAustralian Stage JobsMembers Area

Most Read MELBOURNE Reviews

Big Heart | Dee & Cornelius
Patricia Cornelius and director Susie Dee, collaborators in theatre for over 30 years, team up for another production – Big...
Navy Pier | North of Eight
The minimalist setting and strength of the script combined with the talent of the actor’s keeps the audience on the edge of...
Black T-shirt Collection | Inua Ellams
Technically speaking, this is not a complex play. However, so crisp and affective is the simplicity of the piece, that anyt...
Too Ready Mirror
Too Ready Mirror is a sound attempt to look at why women do the things we do, how we sort out who we are while playing to o...
The Way the City Ate the Stars | Wil Greenway
You’re sitting in a room at the North Melbourne Town Hall, a bare room room with two musicians harmonising sweet, whimsical...