Tuesday, 26 September 2017
Shining City | Hoy Polloy Theatre
Written by Carol Middleton   
Saturday, 02 June 2007 11:18
Shining CityShining City is a cross between a drawing room drama and a play by Pinter, complete with pregnant pauses. Replace the drawing room with a therapist’s consulting room, add a ghost and a touch of postmodernism, and you get the picture.

Directed by Chris Baldock, Shining City is a development of Irish playwright Conor McPherson’s use of the monologue in his earlier plays. In the first of the five scenes that make up this play Ian, a Dublin priest-turned-therapist (Jonathan Dyer) provides a listener for the monologue of John (Ben Grant), a recently widowed man who is disturbed by his wife’s ghost. John is guilt ridden and tormented by the lack of communication in their childless marriage. His tortuous unburdening of his story is fractured, replete with pauses and broken phrases and you knows. It is a daunting marathon for the actor and Grant is not only fluent in this incoherent speech, but riveting in his emotional delivery.

The next of the four scenes takes us into the therapist’s relationship with his girlfriend Neasa (Corinne Davis) and we are privy to his own communication breakdown. The parallels with John’s problems are clear, but the switching of our attention from John to Ian drains the dramatic tension that has been built up in the opening scene. Davis conveys anger and frustration in her more coherent dialogue, but is less comfortable with the truncated sentences that are designed to convey her confusion.

Dyer plays the awkward, passive, monosyllabic character of Ian with a reserved power, although there is a jarring in his switch from therapist to reluctant partner in scene two. It is a relief to see him back in the therapist’s chair for the extended session with his client in the long third scene. Dyer plays the passive listener perfectly, attentive and conciliatory. The undertones of humour surface in the interplay of these two actors and could have been made more of in the other scenes, relieving the rather laboured themes of connection and isolation.

The fourth scene follows Ian’s unraveling personal life into what seems a slightly gratuitous homosexual encounter that adds little to the already dense psychological texture of the play. Dave Kenyon as Laurence shows a little too much sympathy for Ian, who is for him just another meal ticket and another frustrated married man.

A brief final scene shows Ian and John moving on with their lives. All seems well until the final twist, which is chilling and well executed, but seems to have little point. We are left confused, frustrated, abandoned, like the characters in the play. Maybe that is the point.

Hoy Polloy presents
by Conor McPherson

Mechanics Institute Performing Arts Centre | Cnr Sydney & Glenlyon Rds, Brunswick
Friday, 1 June to Saturday, 16 June 2007
Tues – Sat @ 8.15pm; Sundays @ 5.00pm
$30 Adult, $20 Concession/Groups 10+, $18 Tuesdays
03 9388 1942 or This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

{mosgmap mapid=10}
Pin It

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

PozibleAustralian Stage JobsMembers Area

Most Read MELBOURNE Reviews

Big Heart | Dee & Cornelius
Patricia Cornelius and director Susie Dee, collaborators in theatre for over 30 years, team up for another production – Big...
Black T-shirt Collection | Inua Ellams
Technically speaking, this is not a complex play. However, so crisp and affective is the simplicity of the piece, that anyt...
Too Ready Mirror
Too Ready Mirror is a sound attempt to look at why women do the things we do, how we sort out who we are while playing to o...
The Way the City Ate the Stars | Wil Greenway
You’re sitting in a room at the North Melbourne Town Hall, a bare room room with two musicians harmonising sweet, whimsical...
As You Like It | Pop-up Globe
The best night of theatre ever, this. It’s a terrific experience to see a Shakespeare play in an as near to an authentic en...