Saturday, 22 October 2016
Five Kinds of Silence | OpticNerve
Written by Melita Pereira   
Tuesday, 01 July 2008 23:44
Five Kinds of Silence | OpticNerveDaring, innovative and disturbing, Five Kinds of Silence is a play which seeks to shatter the silence around physical violence and sexual abuse.

OpticNerve's production of Shelagh Stephenson's Five Kinds of Silence is a powerful and "disturbing journey into the hidden vortex of familial violence and sexual abuse". The play delves into the lives of Billy, his wife Mary and their two daughters Susan and Janet, revealing how their individual experiences coalesce into their collective reality. Originally written for radio, it is a story propelled by a desire to expose the "destructive cycle of silence and abuse". As the story unravels, Emmaline Caroll as Janet and Ella Watson-Russell as Susan, eviscerate the devastation and distress their characters have endured as a result of their abusive father.

Five Kinds of Silence is visually-arresting. In director Tanya Gerstle's rendition of Stephenson's play, the character's horrendous reality is rendered multidimensional through the visual representation of the actors. Grant Cartwright as Billy, Anne-Louise Sarks as Mary, and Carroll and Watson-Russell physically manifest the anguish and torment which ensnares their characters through sophisticated movement and physical acting. In accordance with Gerstle's bid to elicit a visceral response from the audience, the characters contort and leer, shrink into distorted foetal positions and grip the ground with their bare nails. This visual manifestation of their emotional state makes their intense discomfort and grief palpable to the audience.

The disturbing Billy is deftly embodied by Grant Cartwright who savagely rattles the cages of memory and experience which imprison Mary, Susan and Janet. Cartwright makes his entrance by bursting onto the stage and prowling like a dog. Convulsing and shuddering, his encapsulation of the abusive Billy is revolting and terrifying. Ella Watson-Russell portrays Susan with haunting numbness and presence. Her disclosures, which pivotally disrupt the silence that has shrouded her family life, are tactfully-pitched and delivered with forceful sincerity. The continual oscillation between Billy and Mary's childhood experiences of abuse and Susan and Janet's present abuse operate to both delineate and undo the tightly wound cycle of abuse in the play.

OpticNerve's production of Five Kinds of Silence was bolstered by its effective and apt choice of venue. During the course of the play, the space of Fortyfivedownstairs is repeatedly re-visioned and transformed. Seemingly harmless and previously unnoticed fixtures are employed by the cast, making the space of Fortyfivedownstairs suddenly eerie and garish. Like the use of movement and physical acting, this inventive use of space creatively extends the themes of silence and complacency, situating the audience in the action and grabbing their attention.

Five Kinds of Silence resonates with its radio origins. Stephenson's dialogue reverberates with strong and razor-edged language, capable of delineating the story while also evocatively inciting an emotional response. However, it is the emboldened performances in Five Kinds of Silence which make it such a thought-provoking and memorable piece of theatre. OpticNerve's Five Kinds of Silence is an exceptional and multifaceted production, replete with intelligence, talent and courage.

OpticNerve Performance Group
Five Kinds of Silence
by Shelagh Stephenson

Venue: fortyfivedownstairs, 45 Flinders Lane, Melbourne
Dates/Times: 26/6 – 6/7, Tues – Sat 8pm, Sat/Sun 5pm
Cost: $25 Full / $20 Concession
Bookings: 03 9662 9966 or  
Pin It

Comments (1)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
I agree. Powerful, powerful stuff. See this before it finishes. See it!
Brian G , July 01, 2008

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

PozibleAustralian Stage JobsMembers Area

Most Read MELBOURNE Reviews

The Color Purple | StageArt
StageArt and The Color Purple have shown that there is a world of exceptional musical theatre treats to be savoured beyond...
Two Dogs | National Theatre of China
Two Dogs is one of the most popular works in China and has been performed over a 1,000 times. I wanted in. Twee...
Our Ladies of Perpetual Succour | National Theatre of Scotland and Live Theatre
It’s amazing when you think back to those life changing moments in adolescence – bubbles of clarity caught between the soft...
Super Amazing Giant Girl | La Mama Theatre
There’s no logic, there’s not much plot and the props could have been found in a skip at your local bottle shop, but who ne...
Lady Eats Apple | Back to Back Theatre
Whether you quite understand it or not, Lady Eats Apple is an epic force unto itself, imbued with surrealism, humour and ee...